We Thought The Fountain Would Be Weird. We Were Wrong.

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. This post may also contain other affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission if you make a purchase—at no extra cost to you. You can read my full disclosure here.

If you’re looking for The Fountain by Casey Scieszka review, this is a spoiler-free sister discussion of the book and the first entry in our monthly reading series. We explore immortality, loneliness, grief, and the emotional weight of living forever in The Fountain by Casey Scieszka.

What makes this story especially interesting is how differently two readers can interpret the same book—and that ending is still sticking with both of us.

---

---

Summary

The Fountain follows Vera Van Valkenburgh, a woman who has been alive for over 200 years—but still appears 26. Along with her brother Eli and their mother, Vera is part of a small group of immortals who stopped aging under mysterious circumstances tied to their childhood home in the Catskills.

After centuries of living countless temporary lives, Vera returns home, not to embrace immortality, but to try and end it. She is exhausted by the constant cycle of loss, reinvention, and emotional detachment that comes with never being able to truly grow old or stay rooted in one life.

Disguised as a forest ranger, Vera begins quietly investigating the place where her immortality began, hoping to uncover the truth behind it. But her search becomes more complicated when outside forces—including a mysterious company buying up local land and her estranged brother Eli—enter the picture, pulling her deeper into questions she may not be ready to answer.

At its core, the story blends mystery, literary fiction, and speculative elements to explore a powerful question: what does it really mean to live forever—and is it something worth wanting at all?

---

Format Notes 

Katie read the hardcover edition of The Fountain, while Emily experienced the audiobook — and both formats worked incredibly well for this story.

The hardcover is a quick, immersive read with clean chapter formatting organized by month and year, which makes the shifting timelines easy to follow without ever feeling confusing. The structure naturally pulls you through Vera’s story and makes it difficult to put down.

The audiobook also shines here. Because the story is so character-driven and reflective, the listening experience feels intimate and emotionally engaging, especially during Vera’s quieter moments of introspection.

No matter which format you choose, The Fountain is one of those stories that quietly pulls you in and lingers long after you finish.

---

Review

First Impressions

Katie

Honestly, some of these lesser-known celebrity book clubs pick some C R A Z Y books. When I first saw The Fountain, the cover completely threw me off—I’m not even going to pretend I don’t judge a book by its cover, because I absolutely do. 😅

Because of that, I didn’t give it a second glance…until I spotted it on the “New Books” shelf at my library. Between that and the fact that it had been picked by a couple of book clubs, I figured I’d give it a shot.

And I’m so glad I did.

It didn’t take long at all for me to get invested. Pretty quickly, I realized this was not going to be one of those books I struggled to get through—it completely pulled me in.

Emily

Going in, I’d heard someone describe it as Tuck Everlasting for adults, and honestly? That was all I needed to hear. I love stories that dig into immortality and the emotional weight that comes with it, so I was already intrigued before I even hit play.

And then the moment Vera tried to kill herself and it didn’t work, I was completely hooked. That scene immediately shifted the tone for me and made me realize this story was going to go so much deeper emotionally than I originally expected.

---

Plot & Pacing

Emily

The pacing worked incredibly well for me. This ended up being such a quick listen because I genuinely didn’t want to stop once I got into it.

Nothing ever felt rushed, but it also never dragged. Honestly, I would have happily listened to a version twice this length if it meant getting even more time with these characters and this world.

I also thought the timeline structure was done really well. Sometimes dual timelines or memory-heavy stories can get confusing on audio, but this one flowed so naturally that I never struggled to keep up. The flashbacks were woven into the present timeline in a way that felt smooth and intentional rather than disruptive.

And yes, I was completely invested in uncovering the source of immortality. I’ll admit that at first, part of me was hoping the story would lean more toward discovering and distributing immortality itself. But the direction Scieszka ultimately took ended up being so much more emotional and meaningful than I expected.

As for the ending? I genuinely did not see THAT coming at all.

Katie

I completely agree with Emily about how easy this book was to get pulled into. If time had allowed, I honestly think I could have read it straight through in one sitting—but real life (kids, family, animals…you know how it goes) had other plans.

The pacing really worked for me overall. It never felt like the story was dragging, but it also didn’t rush through important emotional moments either. I especially loved the structure, with chapters organized by month and year and memories woven naturally into the present timeline. It added so much depth without ever feeling confusing.

Like Emily, I was fully invested in uncovering the source of the immortality. But what surprised me most was how emotional the story became along the way. While there’s definitely a strong plot driving things forward, this felt very character-driven to me. Vera’s emotional journey is really what kept me attached to the story.

And honestly, I really felt for her. Living endlessly might sound appealing at first, but this book does such a good job showing how isolating and exhausting that kind of existence would eventually become.

My only real critique comes with the ending. While I loved where the story ultimately went, I do wish we’d had just a little more time to sit with the emotional aftermath because WOW…that ending completely caught me off guard too. I’m still mentally replaying parts of the book because of it.

---

Characters & Relationships

Katie

Vera was easily my favorite character—which isn’t always the case, even with main characters. There’s just something about her that feels very grounded and real. She’s not overly dramatic—she just feels human, despite everything she’s been through.

And honestly, I felt for her. Deeply.

I can’t imagine what it would be like to live for 200 years, constantly losing people you love and never being able to truly settle down. That kind of life would be incredibly lonely, and I think the book captures that so well. Vera comes across as a mix of everything—lonely, resilient, and completely exhausted.

I also really loved the relationship between Vera and her brother, Eli. He’s so many things to her at once. On one hand, he’s her anchor—he calls her every year on the anniversary of when they left, and that consistency shows how strong that bond still is.

But he’s also a source of conflict. He leaves her behind for long stretches, isn’t always there when she needs him, and seems to approach immortality very differently than she does. There’s this constant push and pull between love and frustration.

I also got the sense that Eli might be torn—part of him wanting to keep living, but another part maybe wanting the same thing Vera does: an end.

As for the side characters, some definitely stood out more than others. And some…I just didn’t care for (Lydia 👀), but that felt intentional.

Emily

What stood out to me most was actually the contrast between Vera and Eli. They’re living the same reality, but carrying it completely differently. Where Vera felt like someone who had been slowly worn down by centuries of loss, Eli came across as someone who had found a way to adapt—almost like he’d made a kind of peace with immortality that Vera never could. That dynamic made their scenes together feel so much more layered than a typical sibling conflict, and I loved that the book didn’t really tell you which approach was right.

I also want to add something to what Katie said about Vera’s loneliness, because I think it goes even deeper than just losing people over and over. What got me was how Vera could never fully be herself anywhere she landed. She’s always performing a version of herself that fits wherever she is, and that kind of loneliness—the kind where you can’t even just exist—felt really specific and really sad.

And Katie, yes. Lydia. 😂 We’ll just leave it at that.

---

Writing Style & Atmosphere

Emily  

This book honestly felt like it had a little bit of everything, which made it such an enjoyable experience for me. There was love, mystery, adventure, science fiction, emotional depth, and even some nerdy science woven throughout. It felt like the best parts of multiple genres blended together really seamlessly.

The writing itself balanced emotional and reflective moments with enough forward momentum to keep me completely engaged. And I think the timeline structure helped with that a lot…those glimpses into Vera’s past added so much depth to her character without slowing the story down.

It was also an insanely easy read/listen for me. Nothing about it felt overly dense or difficult to follow, even with the layered timelines and bigger philosophical themes underneath the surface.

And structurally, it absolutely worked for me. Everything felt intentionally placed, and the transitions between past and present were smooth enough that I never felt lost.

Katie

I agree with Emily that this book blends genres together really seamlessly. It has elements of science fiction, mystery, emotional drama, and even a little adventure, but none of it ever feels overwhelming or overdone.

The writing itself felt very approachable to me. It’s not overly heavy or dense, but it still leaves you thinking long after you finish. I wouldn’t necessarily call it emotionally devastating, but it definitely has moments that stick with you.

I also really appreciated how the flashbacks were incorporated into the story. Since it wasn’t structured as a strict dual timeline, the memories felt much more natural—almost like we were uncovering Vera’s life alongside her instead of being pulled back and forth between two separate stories.

Overall, the atmosphere felt very reflective to me, with this constant undercurrent of hope mixed with exhaustion and loneliness.

Also, random sidenote: the word “guffaw” is used a few times throughout the book, and for some reason it made me chuckle every single time. 😂

---

Themes & Takeaways

Katie

At its core, this book really made me think about what it means to have time—unlimited time.

What would you actually do with a life that never ends?

Would you dedicate yourself to something meaningful—helping people, making discoveries, doing something that truly matters? Or would you end up just living day to day, even with all the time in the world?

It also made me think about whether we’d live differently if we were immortal versus mortal. Would we take more risks—or become more guarded, especially knowing we’d have to keep our identity a secret over and over again?

And at what point does that kind of life stop feeling like a gift?

Emily

The biggest theme that stood out to me was the idea that we all think we want more time…but would we actually want forever if the people we love couldn’t move forward with us?

That’s really what stuck with me after finishing the book. Immortality sounds beautiful in theory, but this story explores the emotional cost of it in such a human way. Watching everyone you love age, change, and disappear while you remain the same would eventually become heartbreaking.

I kept thinking afterward about how much value mortality actually gives to life. Maybe it’s not unlimited time that makes life meaningful. Maybe it’s the fact that our time is limited in the first place.

I’d like to think immortality would feel like a gift…but losing the people I love over and over again? That would be incredibly hard. This book really made me question whether eternal life would actually feel freeing or just deeply lonely.

---

Final Thoughts

Emily

Overall, this was a solid 4-star read for me.

I think the book’s biggest strength is how much it makes you think about what we actually wish for as humans. Is more time really what we want? Or is it more about the quality of the time we’re given and the people we share it with?

That emotional and philosophical layer is what really elevated the story for me.

As for weaknesses…I honestly don’t have many major complaints. If anything, I just wanted more time in the world and with the characters because I was so invested by the end.

I’d definitely recommend this to fans of Tuck Everlasting, readers who enjoy low-key science fiction, and anyone who loves character-driven stories with layered timelines and emotional depth.

And yes 🙂 I’m absolutely still thinking about it after finishing. Those are always the books that stick the hardest for me.

Katie

Overall, The Fountain ended up being such an unexpected win for me. What I initially assumed would maybe be an average read turned into one of those books that lingers in your mind long after you finish.

Even with my small critique about wanting a little more emotional payoff at the end, this was easily a 4.5-star read for me.

I think what really made it stand out was how thoughtfully it explored immortality. Instead of making eternal life feel glamorous or exciting, it focused on the emotional weight of it—the loneliness, the exhaustion, and the difficulty of constantly losing people while continuing on yourself.

---

Loved the book and want to keep the conversation going? We put together a full set of discussion questions for The Fountain — perfect for book clubs or anyone who just needs to talk through that ending. 👉 Discussion Questions: The Fountain by Casey Scieszka

Would you live more like Vera, Eli, or Lydia if you were immortal? Share your thoughts in the comments!

---

Ready to dive in? Here’s where you can grab your copy.

---

If you’re still somewhere in the woods with Vera and not quite ready to find your way back, here are a few places to wander:

Casey Scieszka Official Website
Discover more about Casey Scieszka her other book related content, and her beautiful inn in the Catskills.

---

Follow Currently Booked on Instagram
Join cozy book chats, find beautiful quotes, and soak up all the reading vibes.

---

More Magical & Bookish Reads on Currently Booked

I Who Have Never Known Men – A haunting story about a woman who has never known freedom, memory, or connection — and the quiet, unsettling search for what it means to simply exist. If Vera’s questions about meaning and time stayed with you, this one will too.

Where the Forest Meets the Stars – A gentle blend of magical realism and emotional healing, this story explores grief, wonder, and the possibility that the extraordinary appears when we need it most.

---

Other Recommendations

If The Fountain worked for you, here are a few other books that explore immortality, memory, identity, grief, or emotionally layered speculative fiction:

• The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue by V.E. Schwab
  A story about a woman cursed to live forever while being forgotten by everyone she meets, exploring loneliness, identity, art, and the desire to leave a lasting mark on the world.
• Oona Out of Order by Margarita Montimore
  A reflective, emotional story about time, identity, and living life out of sequence.
• Life After Life by Kate Atkinson
  Literary fiction with layered timelines, repeated lives, and thought-provoking questions about fate and mortality.
• The Midnight Library by Matt Haig
  Philosophical and emotional, focused on regret, possibility, and the lives we could have lived.